Posted on 21 Jan 2010
A new California regulation that takes effect next year could prevent long waits for doctor appointments by requiring primary care doctors at health maintenance organizations to see patients within two days for urgent needs and within 10 days for less pressing medical problems.
The regulation makes California the first in the country to limit waits for doctor visits, and is the hard-fought result of the passage of 2002 legislation.
The regulation appeals to those like Brian Benz, who hobbled around for a week after a basketball game left him with a sprained ankle when he lived in Wisconsin.
Though the athletic 34-year-old called his doctor's office repeatedly, he couldn't get an appointment. So he did what many desperate patients do: He went to the hospital for a non-emergency.
Now a California resident, Benz said it usually takes two or three days to go through his HMO to see Dr. Daniel Stone at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center for injuries. "Prior to that, it was hit or miss," Benz said.
The new state regulation will be implemented Jan. 17, 2011, and apply to 21 million HMO policyholders, said Cindy Ehnes, director of the state Department of Managed Health Care.
"What good is health coverage if you can't find a doctor providing services? Or have to drive a really long distance to get that care?" Ehnes said.
The new rule, first sponsored by consumer group Health Access California, faced substantial resistance from health plans, doctors, medical groups and hospitals, said Anthony Wright, the group's executive director.
"Everyone is smiling today, but it took eight years because it wasn't easy," Wright said. "These groundbreaking consumer protections are a victory because wait times are some of the most common complaints."
Wright noted that the rules will empower consumers to know when a wait is too long. He said the lack of timely access has been a telltale of other inadequacies, like provider networks that are too small to serve the number of policy holders HMOs are collecting fees from.
The regulation underwent three rounds of public hearings and drawn-out negotiations prior to this week's announcement.
An insurance industry trade group, the California Association of Health Plans, said the 39 public and private health care plans it represents support the new rule, but many are already in compliance.
"Health plans already have a duty to provide timely access and care to their patients, but these regulations codify that," said Patrick Johnston the trade group's president and CEO.
Some gaps in networks could be helped by technological advances like telemedicine and shared electronic health records, or improved surveys of enrollees, Johnston said.
Enforcement investigations will be based on annual self-reporting from HMOs and consumer complaints to the Department of Managed Health Care. The regulator will be able to demand corrections and issue fines if there is noncompliance.
Dr. Carla Kakutani said the new regulation reflects the speedy care she and colleagues already provide in her multi-specialty group based in Winters, Calif. She leaves open several hours a day for patients with urgent needs.
Where the regulation could make real change is its "onus on the health plans" to make better offers to doctors they want to contract with, Kakutani said. When seeking to broaden their networks, health plans may have to offer more lucrative packages to doctors.
"Something we'd like to see (is) health plans that have reasonable contracts that allows physicians to have" a reasonable number of patients assigned to them for better pay, she said.
Problems in access have been acute in primary care, where doctor shortages have increased wait times.
Dr. Lori J. Heim, president of the American Academy of Family Physicians, says California's mandate could pose real challenges to primary care if the national health care reform policy doesn't pass.
The plan addresses a current shortage of doctors in primary care by luring more medical students to the field with improved loan repayment, an increase to the number of residency slots, and financial incentives for practicing physicians.
New doctors rarely go into family practice because, according to the Council on Graduate Medical Education, the financial difference between a career in primary care and specialty care can be $3.5 million over a lifetime.
According to a survey by Heim's organization, which represents 94,000 American doctors, the average workweek for a primary physician is 52 hours long.
"Most physicians are already seeing as many patients as they're comfortable seeing in a day," Heim said.