Posted on 03 Nov 2009
A.M. Best Co.'s recent four-year study of risk-adjusted capitalization found that the U.S. property/casualty industry experienced a 17 percentage point decline in this measure in 2008, based on A.M. Best's proprietary capital model, Best's Capital Adequacy Ratio (BCAR).
The decline in risk-adjusted capitalization was driven by a combination of a nearly $60 billion drop in reported policyholders' surplus and a reduction in the amount of equity credit given for fixed income securities in the BCAR model. Much of the downward pressure was effectively cushioned by the excess capital built up from several consecutive years of surplus growth prior to 2008, such that the industry's median risk-adjusted capital levels at year-end 2008 remained well above the typical BCAR guidelines for A.M. Best's highest rating level.
Still, ample concerns remain, including competitive pressures (particularly in commercial lines); the negative effects of macroeconomic conditions on exposures and the possibility that some insurers have been too optimistic with the magnitude of favorable loss reserve development taken in recent calendar years on recent accident years.
A.M. Best's study also evaluated risk-adjusted capitalization trends for major market segments (commercial, personal and reinsurance), surplus size and organizational types and found the following:
-- Each of the main segments' median risk-adjusted capital levels remained well above A.M. Best's typical BCAR guidelines for its highest rating level, but only the U.S. reinsurance segment reported an increase in median risk-adjusted capital levels at year-end 2008.
-- Median risk-adjusted capital levels across each surplus size group remained strong. Smaller insurers, however, tended to experience greater year-to-year volatility in the components of required capital than did the larger insurers.
-- While the median risk-adjusted capital for stock and mutual insurers at year-end 2008 remained solid, mutual insurers maintained a higher median score throughout the study period.