Posted on 01 Jun 2010
U.S. insurer AIG said Tuesday it won't accept a lower offer for its Asian insurance business from Prudential, which proposed a $5 billion cut to calm rebellious shareholders who thought the price was too high.
London Stock Exchange-listed Prudential PLC initially agreed to pay $35.5 billion for AIA, the Asian insurance business of American International Group Inc. Faced with the growing possibility that it could not win 75 percent backing from shareholders, Prudential lowered the offer to $30.375 billion.
"After careful consideration, the company will adhere to the original terms of its previously announced agreement with Prudential," AIG said in a statement. "The company will not consider revisions to those terms."
"The board of Prudential is considering its position," the company said in a brief statement to the London Stock Exchange. "A further announcement will be made when appropriate."
AIG, majority owned by the U.S. government, planned to use the proceeds from the sale to repay U.S. taxpayers for some of the $180 billion it got in bailout money during the financial crisis.
Barrie Cornes, analyst at Panmure Gordon in London, said he believed AIG had killed the ambitious deal.
"We think that AIG's response is a surprise given the market movement since the deal was announced and the obvious opposition to the excessive price being paid by Pru's shareholders," Cornes said.
Prudential shares were 6.9 percent higher at 579 pence in midafternoon trading on the London Stock Exchange, a sign that the market would regard the collapse of the AIA deal as positive at least in the near term. Pru shares had been at 603 pence before the announcement of the proposed takeover of AIA.
Prudential needs to line up support from holders of 75 percent of its shares by June 7.
If the AIA deal falls through, Prudential will owe AIG a termination fee of $230.6 million.
Opponents of the deal have formed a Prudential Action Group, which is seeking to muster support for a vote of no confidence in the Prudential's chief executive Tidjane Thiam. The group claims that at least 15 percent of shareholders intend to vote against the deal.
AIG hoped to raise a total $51 billion from the Prudential deal and the sale of its American Life Insurance Co. division to MetLife Inc.
"Clearly as majority owner of AIG, the hand of the U.S. government is writ large over the apparent rejection of price conciliation," said Howard Wheeldon, senior strategist at BGC Partners in London. "Pity, but then again, why should they re-negotiate just because the other side got its sums wrong?"
Prudential disclosed on Tuesday that its lower offer included $23 billion cash, $5.375 billion worth of shares in the combined companies and $2 billion in notes.
Prudential saw the acquisition of AIA as a transformative deal in which the combined company would be earning three-fifths of its profits in Asia. The Pru-AIA combination would have leading market shares in Hong Kong, Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, Philippines, Vietnam, China and India, according to London investment managers Charles Stanley & Co.
AIG's brief announcement gave no clue about what it intends to do if the Prudential deal falls through.
A year ago, AIG had said it planned an initial public offering for AIA shares on an Asian exchange, but never announced a detailed proposal on how large a stake in AIA it would offer or how much it hoped to raise.