Posted on 04 Sep 03
The Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (IIABA) is calling this week's Federal Communications Commission (FCC) decision to delay implementation of a contentious provision of its "Do Not Fax" rule a "significant victory" for business owners and associations, said senior vice president of Federal Government Affairs Maria Berthoud.
The FCC announced late Monday that it had issued a "stay order" or delay of the so-called "Existing Business Relationship" provision that would have prohibited associations and businesses from sending many types of unsolicited faxes to individuals with whom they have a pre-existing relationship. The Do Not Fax rule was published in the Federal Register on July 25 and was scheduled to take effect Aug. 25. Thanks to the FCC's action, implementation of the prohibition will be suspended until Jan. 1, 2005.
From the outset of the FCC's issuance of the Do Not Fax rule, IIABA and its 300,000 members have asserted that the rule is onerous, costly and most importantly anti-commerce. Its compliance provisions requiring a signed permission form for each person being sent faxes by an association or business were reportedly unrealistic, especially given the short lead time before its implementation, and an expensive economic burden for practically everyone impacted by the new rule.
"IIABA firmly believes that the Do Not Fax rule is an unwarranted and unwanted intrusion into business or customer relationships that have been forged over many years," continued Berthoud. "The rules are a government solution to a non-existent problem. It is a shining example of a federal regulator overreaching its mandate to hinder commerce and economic activity. Anybody with even the smallest knowledge of business and association operations knows that it takes considerably longer than 30 days to gather these permission forms from hundreds or thousands of customers or members, and that it would cost a significant amount of resources—time and money—to gain compliance," explained Berthoud.
"In short, the Do Not Fax rules in general, and the existing business relationship prohibition specifically are anti-consumer in that they hinder the flow of commerce," continued Berthoud. "Business owners and associations don't need these types of costly regulations in this difficult economic environment. What our members need instead are common-sense provisions that will boost business activity not dampen growth opportunities, which would have been the net effect of the FCC's rules."
If the new rule had been implemented on schedule it would have created an extremely negative impact on the association community's ability to effectively communicate with its members about valuable member benefits, according to IIABA executive vice president and General Counsel Debra Perkins.
"The FCC rule prohibits anyone from sending unsolicited faxes—regardless of a pre-existing business relationship—on any topic that could be considered an advertisement," explained Perkins. "Even faxes for an upcoming annual meeting or business-related course would require prior written consent from the recipient in order to avoid penalties of up to $11,000.
"While IIABA understand that the foundation of this provision was created with the rights of residential fax users in mind, it creates an onerous restriction on an association's ability to communicate effectively about resources members expect to access through their trade association," continued Perkins. "The effect of this restriction would severely undermine the progress our association has endeavored to make in serving our members by providing them with information and tools to maintain the highest level of professionalism possible."
Because the stay is temporary, Berthoud said IIABA will continue the work it has launched to